One relaxed evening I knitted with scrap yarn without a pattern, fitting to my foot and taking "second sock" notes as I went along, which is my favorite way to knit, and I could tell I was doing something a little differently. I gave the socks to a friend, and she remarked "It fits perfectly!"
The downloadable PDF is fairly detailed. It was posted on January 30, 2015.
The heel is the feature of this sock which begins with a old-fashioned round toe. The foot/ instep is knitted next, followed by a gusset. The first part of the heel starts out just like a short row heel, but earlier. Next is a little cup heel. Then comes the third part of the heel which uses two strip knit methods; first is the usual SKP and P2tog strip knitting, and the second I figured out from an illustration for a pattern called "Sock for a Child" in Mrs Beeton's book (available free online, and reproduced elsewhere on this blog.) Strip knitting usually makes a vertical seam, but the way I figured out makes a gradually increasing seam which melds effortlessly with the previously knitted short rows. Looks nice too.
Here is a summary of the steps followed by notes and some refinements incorporated since the pattern was written.
---
1. Toe
2. Foot
(Rearrange)
3. Gusset
4. Heel Side Short Rows
5. Cup Heel
(Round knitted stripe can go here)
6. Strip Knitting With Decreases
7. Strip Knitting Without Decreases
8. Ankle
9. Leg
10. Ribbing
1. TOE
Casting onto three double-pointed needles can be fiddley, and many of us have found the easiest work around is to use a crochet hook and technique (like amigurumi) to start the rounds in a loop of yarn. In fact, I keep meaning to try making socks with cushy crocheted toes since each crochet stitch has three strands, (compared with knitting which has two strands per stitch, and netting which has one strand per stitch.)
If the yarn is fine I crochet all 8 stitches in the initial loop. Those 8 plus the one on the hook make 9 stitches. Transfer the stitch on the hook to a doublepoint needle, and pick up two more stitches in the outermost legs. Use the second doublepoint to pick up the next three, and the third to pick up the next three. Done! No casting on to three needles or joining without twisting to make a circle. If the yarn is worsted weight or heavy, make a few crochet stitches in the beginning loop, then increase to 6 stitches for round two, and increase into every other stitch for round three (9 total). I use 9 as the base number as the sock will be divided into three sections later. Generally, my socks have a 45, 54, 63, or 72 stitch circumference. If not, no problem. It is easy enough to add a stitch or two later to make the final tube divisible by three, but over 40 years of living with a very literal, number oriented man has taught me to spell everything out. (A couple weeks ago a doctor sized us up, and told us we are polar opposites, and I wouldn't be able to explain his findings to my husband who wouldn't believe me anyway. Exactly!)
I use what is probably an old world school method of round knitting for mittens and sock toes from Ursula von Wartburg's 1973 book "The Workshop Book of Knitting." She immigrated from Switzerland and taught knitting in New York. The decreases are made according to a formula. I know I said formula, but this is from a beginner book for children, so let us plow through this.
If you want a truly rounded toe or mitten, not scandanivian style angles, the trick is to make a series of decrease rounds separated by plain rounds. You alternate the decrease rounds and plain rounds "until the knitting comes to an end." The wonder of her book is it teaches beginners how to knit without a pattern, so forget gauge, leave the pattern books at home, just pick up a tape measure, a ball of yarn and needles and knit! This is the formula: "Divide the number of stitches on the round by 10 and subtract 1." This gives you the number of stitches between each decrease. "If 10 doesnt't fit exactly, use the nearest number that 10 does divide into." If you have 72 stitches, divide 70 by 10 = 7, then subtract 1 = 6. You will knit a decrease, then 6 plain stitches, then a decrease, then 6 plain stitches, to the end of the round. Then knit 6 rounds of plain/straight knitting without any decreases.
The next decrease round will have 5 plain stitches between decrease stitches, and 5 rounds of knitting with no decreases before the next decrease round.
The next decrease round will have 4 plain stitches between decreases, and 4 rounds of plain knitting before the next decrease round. And so on.
Ursula uses "purl two together" decreases, which makes an attractive series of regularly spaced purl bumps. Of course, you can use any kind of decrease you wish. In her book, she breaks it into easy to follow steps. When there are 2 stitches between decreases, you will (decrease 1, knit 1) to the end of the round and plain knit 1 round. The last round is a series of p2tog. Then you "cut the yarn at arm's length, thread it through a tapestry needle. String the remaining stitches onto the yarn and draw them together tightly."
If reknitting a toe, by far the easiest and fastest way to fix a sock that has been knitted too big, or too long, or has stretched over time, simply knit fewer plain rounds between decrease rounds. For the shortest toe knit only 1 plain round between each decrease round.
I work socks from the toe up, so I reversed her directions and used increases instead of decreases. My usual toe up sock has a 64 stitch circumference, so I increase until there are 5 stitches between each increase, then begin the foot. I used to standardize toes with white yarn, but it is hard to wash back to white, so now I'm using black.
2. FOOT
This is the straight tube, and the best place to have fun with color or stitch patterning. For a really close fit use ribbing. Try on the sock, and stop when the toe and foot are 1 inch from the point where the ankle meets the top of the foot.
Now divide the total stitches into 3. This is where my sock differs from most socks, and contributes to the nice fit. Most sock patterns divide the total number of sock stitches into 2; half of the stitches for the top of the foot and half for the heel. For my sock divide the total number by 3, then place them on 4 needles this way:
1/3 on a needle for the top of the foot.
1/6 on a needle for one gusset.
1/3 on a needle for the heel.
1/6 on a needle for the other gusset.
So, you take one third of the total stitches, divide them in half, and one half of these become the right side of the sock, and the other half become the left side of the sock. (This works for sweaters too, 1/3 for the front, 1/3 for the back, and 1/6 for each of the arms.)
3. GUSSET
Continue to knit in rounds, whilst increasing on each side gusset needle until the sock fits snugly on the foot and just touches the point where the ankle meets the top of the foot, or for more negative ease, a little before the ankle. I increase every other round, but like everything else in this pattern do what you like best. Gusset increases can go anywhere; the sides, the bottom of the foot, or the top of the foot. I tried eliminating gussets, and eliminating the "Perfect Fit" heels, and those socks do not fit close to my foot.
Now the knitting changes from round knitting on all four needles to knitting back and forth on three needles. The 1/3 of the stitches that form the top of the foot just rest, while all the knitting is done on the 2/3 of the stitches on the two side needles and the bottom heel needle.
4. HEEL SIDES
Knit back and forth on all three needles, making successive short row turns beginning right next to the resting top of the foot needle. A refinement is to make a wrapped turn for the first stitches of the side gusset needles using the endmost stitches of the top needle, and german doublestitch shortrows for all the rest of the gusset increases on the side needles. Sometimes I goof up and make some turns at the ends of the heel needle, and have to rip it back as that comes later. It is a good thing I am a knitter and not a surgeon, because I goof up a lot. This is also one of the reasons I use circular needles under duress. It is so much easier for me to use visual cues and counts, and keep track of what is happening on each needle than using circulars and markers. Especially when returning to projects after long periods of time. Also the constant pulling of long cables is just not my thing.
Keep making short rows according to the pattern. Not every stitch on the side needles are short rowed. Depending on the weight of the yarn and the numbers of stitches anywhere from 4 to 11 or more stitches closest to the heel needle are left plain. In a perfect world the number of plain stitches will match the number of short rowed stitches on the heel needle in the next section, but it really doesn't matter. What does matter is this is the point where the length of the sock is decided. Socks are to have 10% negative ease, so when fitting the sock to your foot there will still be the cup heel part to knit, which I count as another inch so at this point the sock should be shorter than your foot. You can go by the quality of the yarn too; if the yarn is stretchy merino you will want to end this step sooner than say, a dishcloth cotton.
I usually knit with two colors for socks, and making short rows while changing colors can become complicated, so I change colors at the center of the heel needle, and I make 4 row stripes, not 1 or two row stripes. For a cleaner look I often use only one of the colors for the last two or three stitches before making the turns.
5. CUP HEEL
After completing the short rows on the side needles, knit on the heel needle only, making short row turns on both ends, leaving some center stitches plain. If you leave fewer stitches in the center plain, the sock will be better for narrow heels. If you want a wider heel, leave more plain stitches in the center of the heel needle.
I usually knit with two colors for socks, and this is a good place to knit with alternating colors for each stitch, and as above, I often use only one of the colors for the last two or three stitches before the turns.
Once again, to give the sock negative ease, the cup heel should just barely reach the end of your heel.
This where you can add a stripe around the whole sock, knitting circularly, using all four needles, the top needle too. This functions to clean up the previous short row stitches and adds a nice decorative element, as well as a place to add another color. Be sure to return to back and forth knitting in the next section.
6. STRIP KNITTING WITH DECREASES
This part of the knitting joins the cup heel with the side needles. Decrease on the right side of the work (Slip the last stitch on the heel needle knitwise, knit the first needle on the side needle, pass the slipped stitch over.) Then turn (yep, decide on a short row technique to use here) and purl back the other way. I usually return the combined stitches to the heel needle, as it makes it easier to keep track of which stitches on the side needle have been knitted, and which have not. Whether to make an additional wrap and turn, or double stitch or any other short row method depends entirely on the yarn I am using. At the other end of the heel needle the decreased stitch is purl together the last stitch on the heel needle with the first stitch on the side needle.
7. STRIP KNITTING WITHOUT DECREASES
In the last section the heel joins to the side stitches straight up. At some point you will want to continue joining, but the heel needs to grow so the join will angle towards the toe as usual short rowed heels do. So instead of joining the last stitch on the heel needle with the first stitch on the side needle, you knit first one, then the other, then turn (and use your favorite hole-eliminating short row method as desired here.) Now the joins veer off at an angle, the increases happen effortlessly, and the sock overall develops a more natural organic look and feel than boxy heel flap socks. The other nice thing is the previous two steps make the heel deeper and so fits the foot better than short row heels. And finally, because the heel and side stitches are two thirds of the sock, instead of half of the sock, the heel is deeper yet. So that makes three little refinements that all help these socks fit well.
There are many points where adjustments can be made as you keep trying on the sock as you are knitting it. For instance, once I needed to add length to a sock. I found I could make a series of increases to the center stitches of the heel needle just before making the heel pin short rows and it made the sock a half inch longer. For a high arch gussets can be made deeper, by making more increases. Gussets can be shallower by increasing every row instead of every other row. The number of side needle short rowed stitches is my favorite place to adjust the length of the sock. I end them well before the end of my heel, because the cup heel stitches will happen next. (Actually, I bend my foot and follow the wrinkle line.)
8. ANKLE
Continue attaching the heel to the sides until the stitch count is the same as the foot. Then knit around using all the needles including the top needle. It is possible to stop earlier for a "footie" or here for a short "tennis" length sock and finish it off with a few rows of ribbing.
9. LEG
Keep knitting until the yarn is used up, one of the best reasons to knit toe up, or to make a long sock.
10. RIBBING
My polar opposite thinks no one will want to read all of this as he certainly wouldn't.
Another friend asked for the recipe, and I decided to share it out. Please use it, but please do not add it to a book, or website, or blog, or incorporate it into one of your own patterns, or any other published work. C. Sease put my mother-in-law's nice seam (which I drew, and named Soft Seam) into a book of techniques without attributing it to Nancy Schaeffer, and I'm still majorly pissed off about that. My drawing and the drawing in her book are exactly the same, and my drawing is clearly copyrighted on Ravelry August 16, 2009, so I'm pissed off about that too. The right thing to do would be to notify the publisher to add an attribution line in the errata for subsequent editions, not to claim she saw it somewhere else, not online. Nope, my drawing and my name for the seam can only be found online.